Home / Product Reviews / B7 S4 on OEM S5 19×9 ET33 Peelers

 

5-015ce9a64e37e54dc7718e33b18dbff4d52b0ccaba

Looking back over the past year I realized I never posted pictures of the OEM 19×9 ET33 S5 wheels I ran for about a month – so this post is long overdue! I found these wheels while surfing Craigslist at a VERY attractive price (~$600) and was looking to change it up from my BBS CH wheels at the time, so I scooped these up along with a lightly used set of Michelin Pilot Super Sports to produce the setup pictured above.

3-012c144005eabde63a58d34e98938a8c5dc43c877c

Fitting these was pretty simple – despite the wider wheels and more aggressive offset, the wheels bolted on with no fender rolling or modifications needed other than hubcentric rings, which you can purchase on the right. The B8 platform has a 66.6mm hub and the B6/B7 Audis have a 57.1mm hub, so this ring simply adapts the two – it is very safe and common to run these on aftermarket wheels, including BBS.

I then fitted the wheels with 235/35/19 Michelin Pilot Super Sport tires. The only rubbing occured over bumps or very hard cornering, but nothing too drastic and fine for daily driving. The tires had a very small amount of stretch on a 9″ wide wheel, but nothing to be concerned about and actually looked pretty nice. This entire setup had a very subtle way of being aggressive – from a distance to the untrained eye, it looked like a stock setup. Up close, a real enthusiast can tell they’re wider wheels with an aggressive offset that fits perfectly flush with the B7 fender.

1-01af70816c0a97e6f8b1db6e1cc325e0b55c585b95

My favorite part was the concavity of these wheels – with the aggressive offset and the design of the wheels, they poked out every so slightly and really drew your attention to both the lines of the wheels and the car itself. You can see in the picture above both the amount of stretch in the tire (minimal) as well as the concavity of the spokes for the S5 – this same wheel design was used on the B8 S4 in a 8.5″ wheel with a higher offset and those wheels don’t have nearly as much concavity, so I definitely recommend picking up the S5 wheels over the S4 wheels if you can swing it and don’t mind a tiny bit of stretch and rubbing from time to time.

1-IMG_7444

After running these for a little while, including Targa Trophy, I got tired of having two sets of black wheels so I put both up for sale – these happened to sell quicker, and for slightly more than what I spent on them, so it was a no brainer to let them go. I kind of wish i had kept them and painted them a different color, but they went to a good home and look great on the new owner’s B7 A4. It’s definitely a great setup for someone looking for an OEM plus look, and the fact that they’re OEM wheels means that they’re plenty strong and great for daily use, albeit slightly heavy compared to aftermarket options.

8-01ab95d82cfe9c14517477397b3f4b4f645f0c17b4

On a related note, the Michelin Pilot Super Sports were great tires the short time I had them – nice and quiet, plenty grippy, and a nice tread pattern. I didn’t keep them long enough to do an extended review, nor did I drive on them very hard, but I wouldn’t mind running another set again some day. The only downside to these tires is the price, at nearly $250 a corner, but I was able to pick this set up used for just a few thousand miles for $400 cash on Craigslist, which was a great deal given their condition.

4-01a6dac640739dc0157368da6e175a8a8214d0874e 1-IMG_7415 7-012ebc334b32ff7bc2a92afd8a41ea58db60de6b46

That’s all I  have for pics, hope someone out there finds this post helpful! Leave a comment with any questions or to share a pic of your ride 🙂

 

About the author: Nick Roshon

 

Nick has been an Audi owner and fanatic for the last 10 years, and started Nick's Car Blog in 2009 to share DIYs and pictures of his A4. Currently he drives a 2012 Audi TT-RS, and has previously owned a B7 S4, B7 A4, and an 82 Audi Coupe (GT) LeMons race car. In his day job, Nick is a digital marketer and lives in San Diego, CA, USA.

 

Recent posts in Product Reviews

 

38 Comments

  1. Great writeup as usual nick. I’m a budget audio builder if those 2 things make sense together? However I plan on purchasing peeler reps for the or look.

  2. My pleasure Garrett – Peeler reps will look nice as well. Check out Craigslist though, sometimes you can find used OEM wheels for the same price…

  3. I don’t think you are enhancing performance with wheel rub in bumps and aggressive cornering. Bad idea jeans…. Try bumping performance I hear you can juice 400bhp outta those underpowered engines…

  4. Ha, you are right ray that the 19×9 OEM wheels are neither light nor “performance enhancing” versus stock, it would be more for looks. If you’re in to function over form, check out my latest pair of lightweight forged Volk LE37s: http://nickscarblog.com/featured-rides/photo-shoot-my-b7-audi-s4-on-volk-le37s

    As far as 400HP goes, it’s a tough number to hit naturally aspirated, and that would be crank not drivetrain and there is a TON of drivetrain loss. I really need to get my dyno’d soon, I’ve got pretty much every bolt-on part available short of going supercharged and longtube headers, so it’d be interesting to see what that gets you HP wise.

  5. I too have a Red B7 Audi s4 w/ Platinum Int. My car is lowered on Bilstein PSS9s but not sitting any lower than yours. I was looking at some Avarus AV8 19×8.5 ET32 and when I test fit them, they came past my front fender. I decided not to take them as I was sure that I would damage my fenders. (From what I’ve read elsewhere max is 19×8.5 et37)
    Yours would be another 7mm further out. What I cant figure out is how you are able to drive around without major rubbing and bumps in parking lots must be impossible with the wheel turned. (Thinking the tire would come straight up into the fender)

    Are you sure the wheel size here is correct?

  6. Hi Kevin – the wheels you’re testing are 8.5″ wide versus 9″ wide, so comparing offsets is not apples to apples. Offset is the distance from the center of the wheel, so for instance an the middle of a 9″ wheel has 4.5″ stick out on either side, the middle of an 8.5″ wheel has 4.25″ stick out on either side, and so on. Check out this offset calculator to compare like to like: http://www.1010tires.com/Tools/Wheel-Offset-Calculator# – you can see the 19×8.5 ET32 will stick out 5mm more than 19×9 ET33 despite the offset being within 1mm of each other.

    You can definitely run 19×8.5 ET35 though, that is what my BBS are. They’re very close to rubbing though, so I’m guessing that’s as low as you want to go.

  7. Nick, according to the 1010 offset calculator it shows that my 8.5 et32 wheels compared to your 9″ et33, the 8.5s would be retracted by 5mm. They should fit then.
    arrrrrr this is so confusing

  8. Hi Nick, your ex-wheels looked great. Did you have spacers on there as well if yes, what size?

  9. No spacers, that’s how they fit without any work or modifying other than hubcentric rings to the correct centerbore.

  10. Just picked up some 19×9 peelers for my b7 a4 avant! cannot wait to install them once i get my hubcentric rings the tires are ps2 235-35-19 hopefully they fit with my h&r spring setup

  11. Should be a great setup! Might rub a little in the rear when you’ve got people in the back or are going over bumps but I’d think you’ll be fine otherwise.

  12. Thanks for the fast reply! Can’t wait to post photos

  13. Nick,

    I really like this look. I have a few options I am throwing around and wanted to get your thoughts. Using the calculator you linked to and comparing… I was initially looking at a 19×8.5 ET25 wheel, which would put it 2mm closer to the fenders than yours. Now I am comparing it to a 19×8.5 ET42 wheel, which would be plenty safe for fitment but I would really like to fill the wheel well. What are your thoughts? I have a B7 S4 Avant stock suspension and planning on 235/35/19 tires. I currently have 18×8.5 ET35 Rotiform Nue’s (the ET25 setup would extend almost 10mm further out than I have now).

  14. If you went 19×8.5 ET42 I’d run some 5-8mm spacers just to make it flusher and wider, but that setup would be fine. The ET25 might be a little aggressive, I think that would poke out a little more than you want, even with stretched tires. ET35 is really about the safe zone for an 8-9″ wide wheel, so add or remove at your peril but i’d keep at +/1 5mm if I were you.

  15. Hey Nick! So I just bought S5 wheels. They are 8.5Jx19H2. Would these sit flushed on my B7 A4 base? What size tire would you recommend?

  16. Hi Darith – are you sure those were off a S5? It sounds like they’re only 8.5″ wide. Regardless of 9″ or 8.5″ wide a 235/35/19 will work perfect. How flush it is depends on the offset of the wheels, do you see an “ET” number anywhere on the inside of the wheel?

  17. I’m sorry they came off an s4. The ET is 43

  18. Gotcha. They’ll be about as flush as your OEM wheels then. I’d recommend a 5-10mm spacer depending on how flush you wanna go. 5-8 is probably ideal, 10mm may cause some rubbing.

  19. Awesome! Thanks for the help! Can’t til spring comes to try them on.

  20. Hi Nick,

    I have a b7 S4 on stock suspension. I’m currently searching for a set of S5 peelers. I would also like to run Michelin Pilot Super Sport tires on them. What tire size would you recommend I run on the peelers? Could I run a stock tire size for this wheel since I am on stock suspension?

  21. John, from what I’ve read you can get away with the stock B8 S5 tire size, although the tires are technically taller than the OEM B7 A4/S4 size, so you’ll be running a bigger overall rolling diameter which will throw off your speedometer some, and technically raise your car’s ride height some. If you’re cool with that, it shouldn’t rub so you’ll be fine.

  22. Do the Tire pressure sensors work the same as other OEM sensors? I was told that A5/S5 use a different system then what my 07 a4 sline uses.

    Thanks

  23. Hi Adam – I’m not entirely sure to be honest, I thought TPMS were pretty universal but it’s possible some aren’t compatible with each other. I disabled my TPMS altogether via the VAG-COM and never looked back: http://nickscarblog.com/cars/must-have-vag-com-mods-for-b6-and-b7-audis

  24. Hey nick are you lowered at all? Or stock height? And I have a b6 s4 lowered on bc racing coilovers and I was looking to get some 19×8.5 et35 rotiforms with 235/35/19 tires. Do you think that set up would fit fine?

  25. Hi Ivan – yeah, that setup should be fine even if you lower your car quite a bit. That exact fitment is actually my preferred/recommended wheel, tire and offset specs for anyone who wants to lower their B7, it will sit flush but won’t have any rubbing issues.

  26. Ahmed Tag Eldin

    Hey Nick, great write-up as usual, but I just had a quick question. I recently got some S5 peelers, just like the ones you had, and was planning on getting tires for them in the recent future, what’s the widest tire I can fit without rubbing? I’m currently running 235/45/17 on stock wheels and S-Line suspension on my B7, but originally wanted to go up to at least 245s on the peelers. However, I keep finding mixed reviews all over the forums and whatnot and therefore don’t know if they would fit without issues. Should I just stick to 235s and have that slight stretch, since I don’t know if that 10mm difference would clear? (Also, for reference, future plans may include Eibach pro-kit)
    Thank you very much for your help!

  27. My 235s rubbed in the rear some, so I wouldn’t go wider than that TBH. You could maybe get away with 245s but I think it would rub a lot more than desirable.

  28. Ahmed Tag Eldin

    Awesome, thank you very much for your help 🙂

  29. Picking up this old thread, I have a b6 S4 avant with standard suspension and had tracked down some S5 Peelers and was going to get some 235 35 tyres but the only tyres I have found come with a load rating on 91 when the standard is 95. This seems to indicate that the 235 option is a no no and even 245 seem excessively expensive and again difficult to source as 95 so then to a 255… Would you think this is too big or would running 91 load rating be a silly idea.

  30. While I can’t legally condone it, plenty of people run a lower load rating without any issues whatsoever…I wouldn’t get hung up on it personally.

  31. Thanks Nick, and after even more trawling, I found tyre sites recommending 91 and the door sticker doesn’t give a load rating so I dug out the handbook, it states 91, strange as hell as everyone I’d spoken to in the past says 95 but the weights in the book and eventually finding the weight plaque in the engine bay confirmed it. So 91XL it is.

    Thanks again and it’s my first opportunity to say I enjoy the blog.

  32. That’s really interesting, I need to consult my manual again and see what it advises but yes everyone seems to say 95 but then most people don’t actually run 95, that’s really curious that the manual says 91 is fine lol. I’ve been running 91 on my B7s for over 5 years without concern, and that includes plenty of track days, potholes, etc. so if there is an element of risk, it’s a relatively small one…

  33. Hi Nick, I’m thinking of purchasing a new set of wheels for my Audi A4 B7, 2006, with stock s-line suspension, they are from an Audi A8, 19 inch , 9j wide, with et33, my question is will the car sit on these comfortably? Without any rubbing issues or turning angle issues?, also I plan on wrapping these with 235,35,19, sized tyres, what do you think, will it work?
    Cheers thanks
    Zack

  34. It should fit just fine, same specs as my S5 peelers, but it will look a little funny on the stock suspension since it will poke a bit. I would recommend lowering your car either before or pretty quickly after. Here is what my car looked like on stock suspension at 19s: http://nickscarblog.com/cars/19-wheels-on-stock-b7-audi-s4-suspension

  35. Cheers Nick that’s great, I will be lowering soon, did you have to use any spacers on this set up? And how much millimetres did you lower by? I will post some photos up shortly…

  36. No spacers, not sure how many millimeters I lowered it but low enough that there was just about a finger of gap between the top of the tire and bottom of the fender…

  37. Hey Nick, I’ve decided after a lot of shopping and reading your blog that I want to put 19″ peelers on my B7 A4. Besides purchasing the hubcentric rings, is there anything else I should watch out for or do to make them fit? I would greatly appreciate any help.

  38. Nope you’re all set! Just don’t go too wide on the tires or it will rub, 235/35/19.

Leave a Reply